Everything about food, from matching food and wine to recipes, techniques and trends.

Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

Bob Ross

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

5703

Joined

Sun Mar 26, 2006 10:39 pm

Location

Franklin Lakes, NJ

Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

by Bob Ross » Thu Aug 09, 2007 6:51 pm

The current issue has a very informative article on fraud in Italian olive oil.

One conclusion:

In Puglia, which produces about forty per cent of Italy’s olives, growers have been in a near-constant state of crisis for more than a decade. “Thousands of olive-oil producers are victims of this ‘drugged’ market,” Antonio Barile, the president of the Puglia chapter of a major farmers’ union, told me, referring to illegal importations of seed oils and cheap olive oil from outside the E.U., which undercut local farmers. Instead of supporting small growers who make distinctive, premium oils, the Italian government has consistently encouraged quan-tity over quality, to the benefit of large companies that sell bulk oil. It has not implemented a national plan for oil production, has employed a byzantine system for distributing agricultural subsidies, and has often failed to enforce Italian laws and E.U. regulations intended to prevent fraud. The government has been so lax in pursuing some oil crimes that it can seem complicit. In 2000, the European Court of Auditors reported that Italy was responsible for eighty-seven per cent of misappropriated E.U. subsidies to olive-oil bottlers in the preceding fifteen years, and that the government had recovered only a fraction of the money.

There is a great deal more on the subject, and a totally unrepentant former dealer, with an interesting spin on the subject:


Marseglia estimated that ninety per cent of oil sold in Italy as extra-virgin isn’t of premium grade. “It’s anything but extra-virgin, the oil we have here,” he said. He did not seem to think that this was a problem. “First of all, let’s give people good oil,” he said. “Then the excellent—all the extraordinary stuff at forty or fifty euros a kilo, which a few idiots in the world can afford—we’ll think about that later, no?” He told me that his family uses ordinary oil: “For us, the concept of ‘good’ is enough. We want to be average folks.”

Over lunch in the Casa Olearia canteen, Marseglia showed me what he meant by good oil. Techniques like strippaggio are “all hot air,” he said. “Tasting a plate of pasta is easy. Tasting a glass of wine is easy. Tasting a piece of fruit is easy. Tasting oil is the same. It has to have the same pleasurable tastes. If it has an unpleasant one, it’s not good—that’s pretty simple. They say you need a lot of knowledge to understand it, because they want to make the subject seem more intellectual.”

He reached across the table for a bottle of Giusto, his company’s supermarket label, unscrewed the cap, and pointed it at me. “Smell this. Does it smell good, or stink?”

It smelled good: a tart, intensely green fragrance that I’d come to associate with coratina, a popular olive cultivar in Puglia.

Marseglia brought the bottle to his lips and tipped in two big glugs. “So you put it in your mouth, right?” he said thickly, through the oil. “Either it’s disgusting, and you spit it in somebody’s face, or it’s good.” The sign of a good oil, he went on, is the bocca bella (“pretty mouth”), the pleasant taste and sensation that remains in the mouth after you’ve swallowed the oil.

Marseglia passed me the bottle. “Now you taste it, without doing what those other guys do,” he said. “Pretend you’re eating a candy, something good. Then we’ll see how it leaves your mouth.” He watched my face intently as I swallowed the oil, then nodded, satisfied. “Tasting things is simple,” he said.


The article has a fascinating history of how the ancient Romans tried to prevent fraud (concluding that current regulations are much less effective than they were 2000 years ago) and a good description of tasting olive oil.

A very good article, available for awhile, at least, free online.

Slippery Business; the Trade in Adulterated Olive Oil
no avatar
User

Hoke

Rank

Achieving Wine Immortality

Posts

11420

Joined

Sat Apr 15, 2006 1:07 am

Location

Portland, OR

Re: Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

by Hoke » Thu Aug 09, 2007 10:22 pm

I read that article, Bob. And while it was interesting reading (as are most things in the New Yorker) my primary reaction was, "Well, it took them long enough to figure it out."

This has been common knowledge for quite a few years, I'm afraid. Virtually anyone that sells olive oil knows it. And it's been that way for a long time.

Heck, I remember vividly talking to a Venetian restaurant owner, who freely admitted that the vast majority of "Italian" olive oil was actually from Spain and Greece. And he paid little attention to the labels, except for the ones that were small families and well known to him. He said "There are about as many extra virgin olive oils as there are virgins over twenty...and not in a cloister...these days. But every one winks and nods, because they know their daughter must still be a virgin, just as they know their favorite olive oil must be pristine and pure."
no avatar
User

Bob Ross

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

5703

Joined

Sun Mar 26, 2006 10:39 pm

Location

Franklin Lakes, NJ

Re: Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

by Bob Ross » Thu Aug 09, 2007 10:37 pm

Great story, Hoke, thanks.

I agree that it's an old, old story -- I remember reading about manipulation of the olive oil trade during my college Latin I course many years ago. The article alludes to how a couple of Spanish emperors favored the oils from their home regions.

It appears, though, that the independent tasting panels have been eliminated, and the Italian government has taken more actions to weaken Italian quality oils.

I was struck by a couple of points: the contrast between approach of the expert tasters and the renegade oil importer -- a lesson there for some of the pretentious wine tasters I know.

And, even small producers, apparently can't be entirely sure that their workmen aren't adulterating their oil.

One big message to me: check oil for taste and don't pay too much. Even the adulterated oils may taste pretty darn good. :)
no avatar
User

Stuart Yaniger

Rank

Stud Muffin

Posts

4348

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 7:28 pm

Location

Big Sky

Re: Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

by Stuart Yaniger » Thu Aug 09, 2007 11:03 pm

It's pretty common knowledge around here that many of the premium California oils have an irregular provenance. One of the best known (and their oil is darn good) sells California-labeled oil that's actually Tunisian.
no avatar
User

John Tomasso

Rank

Too Big to Fail

Posts

1175

Joined

Tue Mar 21, 2006 4:27 pm

Location

Buellton, CA

Re: Fraud in the olive oil business from the "New Yorker".

by John Tomasso » Fri Aug 10, 2007 8:29 am

My father took pride in the wide selection of brands of Italian olive oils we offered in our store, but he always said it was probably all from Morocco.

I loved this:
He reached across the table for a bottle of Giusto, his company’s supermarket label, unscrewed the cap, and pointed it at me. “Smell this. Does it smell good, or stink?”

and this:
“So you put it in your mouth, right?” he said thickly, through the oil. “Either it’s disgusting, and you spit it in somebody’s face, or it’s good.”

and of course, this:

“Tasting things is simple,”

All things considered, he sounds like a pretty wise man.
"I say: find cheap wines you like, and never underestimate their considerable charms." - David Rosengarten, "Taste"

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: ClaudeBot, Ripe Bot and 7 guests

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign