Dave R wrote:And that reminds me of why I was such a strong advocate (on the old FLDG) for people posting recipes they had actually tried and found were acceptable. But that fell on deaf ears.
I have a high level of confidence in the recipes that are tried and proven good by the people here, but do not trust a recipe posted on a place like about.com. The above recipe is a great example.
<nodding> I don't think we've ever set it as a firm rule, but I take it as understood that when a FLDG regular posts a recipe, it's one they've made, with the possible exception of a dinner-to-be posted for the specific purpose of recipe analysis.
I dislike firm rules, but I think this is a good general guide.