by Mike Filigenzi » Tue Dec 09, 2025 1:53 pm
I went off on a mushroom foraging class this past Sunday. We foraged in a state park along the Sonoma Coast and lucked into a perfect day, with blue skies and temperatures in the 50s. It was a lot of fun crawling around under huckleberry bushes in a beautiful, bug-free forest. After a couple of hours, we all gathered with our instructors who went through our baskets and ID'd everyhing so that we could throw out the undesirables. I learned all sorts of things, including the following:
- There is such a thing as a Beefsteak mushroom, which is very large and when cut into slices, looks just like slices of raw, marbled beef. Something of a Wagyu mushroom.
- Beefsteak mushrooms are among the very few wild mushrooms that can be eaten raw. Usually prepared along the lines of carpaccio, sliced thin with a little mild olive oil on top.
- Amanita muscaria mushrooms (the ones with the bright red caps with little dots on them) can be edible, psychotropic, or toxic, depending on how you use them. They do contain the toxins ibotenic acid and muscimol, but can be detoxed by boiling in a couple of changes of water. According to our instructor, they handle this well and are a bit like scallops in texture once you do this. I'm not tempted - this sounds like more work than it would be worth.
- There are many more types of edible wild mushroom than I would have guessed. (That's just including the ones that are considered edible and desirable vs. edible but not great.) On the other hand, based on what I've tasted so far (which isn;'t that much), I can understand why many of them aren't being sought after by chefs. Flavor can be very mild and easily compromised by adding much of anything to the pan. The Beefsteak, for instance, can barely take a little mild olive oil without killing what flavor it has. Furthermore, cooking it improves the texture but also reduces the flavor. I also came home with hedgehogs and violet chantarelles but haven't tried them yet. There's a class in the spring that's focused on morels and spring porcini. I hope to attend that one as those are mushrooms I know I like!
"People who love to eat are always the best people"
- Julia Child