by Frank Deis » Thu Apr 28, 2011 2:52 pm
Thanks Jacques, I have ordered the book.
FWIW we went through a real Italian/Tuscan cooking phase about 10 years ago, and I particularly liked the soups. I cooked through a couple of good Italian cookbooks (Bugialli, and I think Kasper's book The Splendid Table) doing all the soups. The ONE soup that gave me trouble, and embarrassment with guests, was an Acqua Pazza. At least in Bugialli's recipe, the big problem is that you can't taste as you go along. You have no idea how things are turning out and you can't adjust to taste because it tastes watery or even bad right up until the end. In that recipe I think you stir in a lot of grated Parmigiano and an egg or two right at the end, which if you have done everything else right, gives you a delicious soup. Despite the fact that I am a chemist I sometimes get a little glitchy with quarts and gallons and pints, so occasionally I would end up adding too much water at some stage and end up with a diluted excuse for soup that eventually tasted excellent, but only after a couple of hours of gentle reduction. You can't leave your dinner guests at the table for a couple of hours... I quit making that soup. All the others turned out beautifully, including some that you wouldn't even realize were Italian if you were just served the soup out of context. I think Kasper has a mushroom soup that has a beautiful dark clear broth, and a huge flavor from a mixture of dried porcini and sliced mushrooms of other sorts.
I realize your Acqua Pazza is something quite different but it reminded me of the one I attempted a few times.