[Since I had suggested this topic, I felt compelled to actually contribute something to the discussion]
With tonight's dinner of broiled lamb, Jean entreated me to find a good lamb wine. What better choice with lamb than Bordeaux? So, off to find a good example in the cellar. One ulterior motive was Jean's recent observation that her recent Bordeaux experiences had failed to excite her. I decided to open something that would be better than just "all right." What I came back with was:
2000 Ch. du Tertre Margaux
nose: pencil lead, red/black plummy fruit, herbal, sous bois
palate: resolved tannins, firm backbone, medium body, fairly primary
This wine came from a mixed case of '00s we purchased with a group some years ago. Still fairly young, the wine was nonetheless reasonably mature and very enjoyable. Jean loved the wine, finding it "meaty" as well as hugely fruity. Fairly traditional in nature, this wine went splendidly with the lamb. I am glad that we have more of it in the cellar, and I plan to wait on the remaining bottles for quite a while
longer.
Mark Lipton