Steve Edmunds wrote:Walt; the question really is: are you planting the fruit in the right place? If you put Albarino or Pinot Gris or Gruner Veltliner in the right spot in CA, you can get the same kind of "European" structure and balance, the brightness and nervosity. I do think that's something people haven't really thought about much, out here in Dreamland.
Steve,
I am sure you are correct and you do a great job of selecting vineyard fruit. I am also sure that many people plant whatever they want anyplace they have some space and therefore end up with just wine. I guess to my uneducated mind, sun and heat is the concern for West Coast whites. In the extreme I go back to Riesling. I doubt any west coast riesling could approach German wines or even Austrian for that matter. I probably mistakenly equate low acid with hot climates and this is my problem with most west coast stuff. Maybe it is too ripe fruit, poor planting locations or just not letting the vineyard show through. Not trying to heap praise on your head but you, and I am sure a handfull of others, are the exception. Your syrahs have good acidity, love the Rousanne plus several others. In general I am a regionalist, which certainly evokes polite criticism from Hoke. If I want a sangiovese I will go to Tuscany, if riesling to Germany, if CB to the Loire, if cab to the west coast, if grenache the So of France or Spain, on and on and on. Again, kudos to your wines, the good news is that they are some of the best available. The bad news is that you need to cellar the good ones for several years to realize their potential. Ever think about making a really goopy syrah that must be drunk immediately after bottling and then falls apart?
Walt