ooooh.....I'm so bad at this recommendation thing that I'm gonna apologize in advance. Also, I've not try ANY 05's yet. There must be many burg fans on this form that can do a better job than me!
(please help...I would love to hear more and learn more too!)
What I did was what my pusher suggested, just buy what you know and what you can afford which seems to be the general rule in Burgundy. With this vintage they told me that you can be adventerous and buy anything you want to try and it should be okay but being short on cash means that I won't be able to traverse this region like I would like to. I've always liked Pousse d'Or (my few years of wine experience) adn this year they are about $50 per bottle. Hudelot Noellat's prices were very fair (mid $40s for their lower mid offerings) so I bought that. So those were my budget buys. Lafarges are also around this area and love his wines.
Comte Armand's Pommard (which should pack a bit of a punch this year) was a bit more expensive but okay(just north of $100). I'm not sure what the Roumiers will cost this year but the futures are already around $100-$135 but I love his wines so this will be my one splurge...most likely for a case of his Morey Saint Denis.
I'm pretty sure that I won't be able to affort the Dujac's, Faiveley, Meo Camuzet, etc, so not even looking. I will start to also look at other less expensive regions like Mercurey and Givry. Francois Raquillet Mercurey Vieilles Vignes ($20+) was pretty decent (lighter style) in 2002 but have not tasted their '05's. Domain Francois Lumpp Givry 1er Cru Petit Marole was very nice in 02 and will be looking for his 05's as well.
Hopefully not a waste of bandwidth here. just my $0.02.