by Jenise » Mon Mar 30, 2026 11:43 am
Re the St. Peray, did we drink the same bottle? My notes indicate deep yellow gold--it looked old, and it tasted older, and it oxidized while sitting in our glasses. I had a bottle a year ago that showed signs of this progression, so it's not just your bottle. Drink up!
I brought the Jim Barry Assyrtiko. Thought a Greek grape grown in Australia by a top producer would be fun one to "stump the chumps", and it did not disappoint. The first guess was riesling due to the fair amount of diesel, following by sauv blanc, zarelho, semillon, NW rhone variety, GV and just about everything else before everyone gave up. Fun!
Kim's Montus was another great stumper and inarguably delicious. Rich and complex with gold grapefruit notes. Most of us have never seen a white Madiran before. Didn't even know they existed.
Alvin's '83 Pesquera --what a delight. Full tertiary, showed so well. Then came your Produttori, also excellent. At this point observed, "Bill's wine cellar is like the guy who owns a Ferrari but lives in a place where the speed limit is 40 mph." Then came my favorite of the day, Sue's perfectly-aged, red-fruited '95 Les Cailloux, which was warm and happy.
Bob A's young and earthy Roilette was a reminder of how great a grape gamay can be. After getting burned on the '18s I swore I'd never buy Roilette again but this will force me to rethink that. Then John's Musar which had aromas like nothing that came before--not American, not European but "something special from somewhere else", as I wrote in my notes while trying to put a name to what I was experiencing. Lebanon--somewhere else indeed.
Lastly my sad little '06 Jasmin CR. 'Angular' is a very apt word. Bill. A recent note on CT said it was full tertiary, but this wasn't that far along at all. Worse, it was just odd, not mousy odd but--well, angular! I took the remainder home and tasted it again the next day, where it was now in full green-meanie mode. I fed it to the rhododendrons. Sorry!
Then lastly John's delish Muscadet in a Jura shaped bottle that wasn't a Jura. Very clever in a blind tasting! It was very nicely developed but not fully mature. Nice!
My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov