The place for all things wine, focused on serious wine discussions.

WTN: Three Natural Whites...(short/boring)

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

TomHill

Rank

Here From the Very Start

Posts

7891

Joined

Wed Mar 29, 2006 12:01 pm

WTN: Three Natural Whites...(short/boring)

by TomHill » Thu Nov 26, 2020 2:52 pm

Tried these three from Kokomans ystrday:
1. Fran Ehrhard "naturich" Riesling Rheingau (trocken; 12.0%; "Frmtd w/ natural yeast for 18 mo. in old/traditional wooden barrels"; U; Los# 201709; ScopertaImprts/ClevelandHeights/OH; www.ScopertaImports.com) 2017: Med.dark gold color; very quiet almost no nose; very light R/floral/mango slight chalky/earthy pleasant enough if unthrilling nose; totally dry very tart/acidic austere/lean very sloght floral/R/mango rather earthy/chalky quite tangy/metallic/steely almost vapid flavor; short totally dry very tangy/acidic very light R/floral/mango/chalky/steely rather vapid/eviscerated finish; almost no nose or flavor but an abundance of acid; this is how Duncan & Nathan would make R in the Rheingau if they could; hurty to drink. $22.50 (KK)
_________
2. Vina Gonzalez Bastias Naranjo MauleVlly/Chile (12.3%; 40% Pink Moscatel/40% Torentel/20% Pais; Natural orange wine, aged in Chilean Rauli foudres; Imprtd by BrazosWineImprts/Brooklyn; www.BrazosWines.com; Vino turismo del Maule) Sector Nirivilo San Javier/MaulyVlly/Chile 2019: Lots of effervescence that dissipates; med.gold/slight browning quite cloudy color; rather earthy slight fragrant Moscatel fairly funky/bit mousey/hantavirus/natty slight graham cracker/CinammonHoneyCrisp rather bizarre/unattractive nose; soft off-dry )0.5%-0.7% r.s.?) quite natty/hantavirus very earthy bit tangy/metallic rather unclean/funky virtually no fruit unattractive flavor; med.short quite tangy/metallic funky/hantavirus quite unattractive finish; another dog of a natty wine. $25.50 (KK)
_________
3. Via Revolucionaria Torrontes Brutal Passionate Wine (12.5%; BrazosWineImprts) Viticultor: Matias Michelini/Tupungato/Mendoza/Argentina 2019: Med.dark gold color w/ lots of bubbles that dissipate; quite cidery some phenolic/resiny/skin-contact some cheap hair oil/Torrontes some herbal/Kansas hay mow rather strange nose; very tart/tangy/acidic some cidery/VinoMacerati/phenolic slight cheap hair oil/Torrontes rather metallic/tannic flavor w/ some oxidation; med.long very tart/acidic slight Torrontes/hair oil fairly phenolic/VM/quite cidery some bitey/tannic finish w/ slight wet dog fur/oxidation in the aftertaste; a pretty unattractive/hurty VM. $21.50 (KK)
________________
A wee BloodyPulpit:
1. Ehrhard: This is the first "natural" wine from Germany I've seen or tried. I presume it was not a QmP wine because it was so atypical of Rheingau. Pretty unattractive/vapid stuff.
__________
2. Batted 0-3 on these natural wines. It seems to me that they are much more successful w/ Natural wines in Calif than in Europe.
Tom

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: AhrefsBot, ClaudeBot, Dale Williams, Google [Bot], SemrushBot and 1 guest

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign