Herb encrusted lamb is my favourite pairing with red Musar (and older Riojas). Excellent choice of dish you had!
Though I usually love Musars, I must admit that I am a little iffy on the 1977 - or then all the three bottles I've tried have been a bit off. But if you'll bear with me, I'll give a fairly convincing account of why I think the bottles haven't been off, and why this is one of the oddities of tastes.
Serge Hochar thinks the '77 is his greatest wine. When he came to Finland recently, he had chosen this vintage to show what Musar at its best will turn into. Just like the previous two times I've tried the wine, I thought that the nose had a strange cardboard-like note to it, almost, but not quite, like it were corked. But there was such an intensity of fruit that cork just does not seem plausible. Also I have tasted this twice with a friend who is hyper sensitive to cork taint and who loved the two bottles we had and didn't note the cardboard scent. So what could that almost cork-like scent be? I don't know. But though I am usually more into the scent of wines than the taste and will spend hours swirling and sniffing a glass, this is one of the few wines where I like the taste more than the scent.
But that taste! That is one of the most beautiful tastes of all. If I could only tune out that cardboard frequency from the nose, I would agree with Serge Hochar and almost everyone else that this is the greatest Musar ever made. If anyone wants to send me a few bottles to try again, just in case I tried very slightly off bottles, I'll send my address.
-Otto-
I don't drink wine because of religious reasons ... only for other reasons.