The place for all things wine, focused on serious wine discussions.

Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Noel Ermitano » Sun Apr 28, 2013 3:10 am

Friday, the 12th April 2013, was the last full day in France of this trip. My old friend, the Doc, had messaged me on Facebook a couple of days earlier, recommending that I have lunch at La Tour d'Argent (15 Quai de la Tournelle 75005, Paris, France), for the ambiance and the voluminous, deep, Burgundy-focused wine list. As regards the food, he suggested we just stick with the house specialties of foie gras and the pressed duck.

Image

I made lunch reservations for the whole family on short notice, but, since we had dinner that night scheduled at the house of friends, Catha wanted to spend the last full day in Paris doing last-minute shopping. So, it turned out to be just the boys and I for lunch - which was fine.

Image
Kir Royale apéritifs with...

Image
...a plate of Foie Gras & Pistachio Amuse Bouche.

Image
The restaurant serves a kir royale that merits a little discussion: they actually use decent bubbly, and...

Image
...just the right amount of good crème de cassis, so it is bright, and not cloyingly sweet or syrupy, unlike most others.

Image
Some in-season Asparagus Soup to warm us up on a cold, rainy day.

Image
I had mentioned to the kids what the Doc had recommended...

Image
...so we all wound up having the same things for lunch...

Image

...starting with identical entrées of Foie Gras d'Oie des Trois Empereurs, Brioche au Beurre Salé (Goose Foie Gras of Three Emperors, with Brioche & Salted Butter). The foie gras is scooped and served like ice cream, the substantial chunks of black truffles readily visible when served. Each serving is of two generous scoops, accompanied by Sauternes Jelly & Port Jelly.

The foie maintains its integrity, but is silken and creamy. There is no trace of any veins. The truffles add a nice, refined, subtly perfumed earthiness. Good as it was, one scoop was all I could take, so the kids finished their own respective servings, then divvied up my second scoop.

Image

Our main courses were likewise identical. Each order of the eponymous signature Caneton Tour d'Argent (Tower of Silver Duckling) is good for two persons and served two ways, so, since we were four for lunch, two orders of the signature dish were perfect. The first way is a juicy, moist, perfectly rare-to-medium rare duck breast slathered in a sauce of its own juices, champagne, and thickened/flavored with the duck's blood.

Image
The first way comes with a side of Pommes Soufflés (Potato Puffs).

Image
Since my shot was back-lit, here is Lorenzo's shot of his serving.

Image

The second way the duck is served is a confit of the duck legs in a lighter, though still rich, sauce of its juices. It was just ok; and I could certainly live without it. Later on, Doc told me that his second way was a crisp-fried confited leg served as it is usually served back in Manila (which he prefers).

Image

Since Mauro's birthday was in a few days (and he & Lorenzo would be busy with summer classes in college when we got back home), I had ordered a birthyear wine for him: 1993 d'Angerville Volnay 1er Cru Champans - When I ordered it, the very friendly and charming sommelier smiled and said: "I know you know Champans because you choose d'Angerville." 1993 also happens to be a pretty good year for red Burgundy. I mentioned to the sommelier the reason for my choice of this particular year, to which he nodded and replied: "I understand why you choose the vintage."

The wine was lovely. Nice depth and complexity, with the notes of ceps, sous boise, and wistful, sadly-sweet Burgundy decay and discreet iron & sanguine suggestions woven seamlessly in its soft, pliant dark fruit. Halfway between medium to full-bodied, the acidity is precise, and notably less torrefactive and oevr-ripe than their vintage 1990 (which I like a lot anyway).

It was also good to be able to have this as I had, a few weeks earlier, placed an order of a few bottles of this in HK through fellow wino/good friend/drinking buddy, Alex Tiu.

Image
My dessert was Citron, Meringue, Sablé à l'Huille d'Olive ( Lemon Meringue with Olive Oil Shortbread). Excellent.

Image
Joaqi's was the Palet Chocolat Tour d'Argent, Crème Glacée au Pain Grillé (Tower of Silver Chocolate Puck with Ice Cream and Toast).

Image
Lorenzo's was Soufflé Caramel, Fruits Exotiques au Jus de Citronelle (Caramel Soufflé with Exotic Fruits in Lemongrass Juice).

Image
Mauro's was Poire Vie Parisienne (Parisian Life Pear).

Image
Top view of Mauro's pear dessert.

Lorenzo actually was to meet up with some friends that afternoon, and, since lunch was running long (already around 3pm when the desserts were served), he was already late. Thus, he quickly downed his soufflé and left...

Image
...the eye-catching friandises to the remaining three of us.

Image
Too bad, as these chocolate petits-fours were particularly good.

Image

As we were about to leave, the sommelier gave Mauro an envelope which, upon opening, we saw contained a card with our bottle of red's label on it, because it was a birthyear wine.

I must say that, even though La Tour d'Argent currently has "only" 1 Michelin star (having had 3 for decades), its impeccable service is virtually unrivaled, its food good, the wine list stunning, the ambiance and view of the city captivating. For these reasons, I can easily think of quite a few Michelin-starred restaurants (from one to three) that I would prefer La Tour d'Argent over any day of the week. Thanks, Doc, for making me finally eat here, as well as the recommended dishes.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Image

Since it was raining quite hard when we left, we hopped into a cab back to the apartment. Lorenzo was still out with his friends and Catha was back from shopping. Since Mauro wanted to change and return to the Louvre, I accompanied him there, but just hung out in my nearby usual spot in the Tuileries - having my double espressos, smokes, taking in the cold weather and the scenery.

That evening, I suffered a bout of crise de foie, i.e., indigestion which the French call/attribute to a "crisis of the liver", so I begged off dinner at Jean-Marc & Caroline's - all the rich meals over the past 3 weeks catching up with me, no doubt. I myself didn't eat that night, but did venture out to accompany the two college boys for a very late dinner and drinks (around 10pm) at Les Garçons (79 rue du Cherche-Midi 75006 Paris, France), a simple café-bar filled with young locals, barely 150 meters down our street. I just had some cognac to ease my discomfort. The boys had the tartare de boeuf, magret de canard, some beers, and some single malt, but I was in no mood to take any photos.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Epilogue

So, with that ends my series of posts on the subject trip. We were homeward bound early evening of the following day, Saturday, the 13th April 2013. By noontime, we were on the way to CDG, where we checked in our luggage, went through immigration, and whiled away the hours shopping in the duty-free stores and surfing the web.

A couple of final notes, though: food and drinks at CDG are dismal at best. One would think a major Parisian airport would have halfway-decent (by Parisian standards) food/drink outlets - even past immigration.

Image

As it was, I had to deal with a better-off-forgotten jambon au fromage sandwich and the above lousy, watery, commercial adjunct Italian beer for merienda. Bleah. Let's not even talk about the airplane food on the long flight home.

Image

Upon our eventual arrival back in Manila, all I had left were the memories of the crisp, cold weather and the unforgettable past 3 weeks in France with Catha and the boys. Well, a couple of large boxes of assorted Ladurée Macarons did somewhat mitigate the merciless heat and humidity of Manila's summer. Until the next.
no avatar
User

Hoke

Rank

Achieving Wine Immortality

Posts

11420

Joined

Sat Apr 15, 2006 1:07 am

Location

Portland, OR

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Hoke » Sun Apr 28, 2013 12:52 pm

Thank you, Noel, for allowing me the vicarious experience of Paris, and for rekindling some cherished memories.

I have a fondness for La Tour d'Argent based upon some delicious meals---no, not meals, experiences---there, and agree that with only one star and faltering a bit in au courant coolness, La Tour is still and always will be, a standout. You mentioned the impeccable service, some of the dishes they have immortalized, the gracious setting and the incredible view; and of course the cellar of envy. The first time I dined there the old man, Claude was holding forth in all his splendor---what a grand old presence he was in his dining room.

I'm with you: one scoop of Trois Empereurs is sufficient thereunto. And the duck looks great, as always. Had I been there (and I wish I had), I would have added only one thing, for old time sake: the Quenelles Andre Terrail, which I cannot resist.

Of course, had I been there I might have offended your son by piggishly commandeering large portions of his pear dessert, so it's as well I wasn't there.

You brought back even more fond memories from the Rue de Cherche-Midi---for much the same reasons, lingering long at an otherwise indistinguishable cafe-restaurant with the menu du jour. Cherche-Midi is one of my favored streets in Paris: it's not as flashy or gilded or precious as many more popular streets, but it resounds of la vie Paris in a special and uncompromising way, partly dowdy, partly gritty, partly touristy and partly fashionable as only Paris can be.

So, thank you.
no avatar
User

Jenise

Rank

FLDG Dishwasher

Posts

45496

Joined

Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:45 pm

Location

The Pacific Northest Westest

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Jenise » Sun Apr 28, 2013 1:40 pm

After reading all these reports, my bags are all but packed. Thank you so much for the tour!
My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov
no avatar
User

Jon Peterson

Rank

The Court Winer

Posts

2981

Joined

Sat Apr 08, 2006 5:53 pm

Location

The Blue Crab State

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Jon Peterson » Mon Apr 29, 2013 8:29 am

Jenise wrote:After reading all these reports, my bags are all but packed. Thank you so much for the tour!


...and credit card limits increased ten-fold!
no avatar
User

Diane (Long Island)

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

744

Joined

Fri Apr 07, 2006 6:47 pm

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Diane (Long Island) » Mon Apr 29, 2013 6:11 pm

And I am really trying to get a reservation via their website, and I haven't heard back.
Diane
no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Noel Ermitano » Mon Apr 29, 2013 10:43 pm

Hoke wrote:Thank you, Noel, for allowing me the vicarious experience of Paris, and for rekindling some cherished memories.

I have a fondness for La Tour d'Argent based upon some delicious meals---no, not meals, experiences---there, and agree that with only one star and faltering a bit in au courant coolness, La Tour is still and always will be, a standout. You mentioned the impeccable service, some of the dishes they have immortalized, the gracious setting and the incredible view; and of course the cellar of envy. The first time I dined there the old man, Claude was holding forth in all his splendor---what a grand old presence he was in his dining room.

I'm with you: one scoop of Trois Empereurs is sufficient thereunto. And the duck looks great, as always. Had I been there (and I wish I had), I would have added only one thing, for old time sake: the Quenelles Andre Terrail, which I cannot resist.

Of course, had I been there I might have offended your son by piggishly commandeering large portions of his pear dessert, so it's as well I wasn't there.

You brought back even more fond memories from the Rue de Cherche-Midi---for much the same reasons, lingering long at an otherwise indistinguishable cafe-restaurant with the menu du jour. Cherche-Midi is one of my favored streets in Paris: it's not as flashy or gilded or precious as many more popular streets, but it resounds of la vie Paris in a special and uncompromising way, partly dowdy, partly gritty, partly touristy and partly fashionable as only Paris can be.

So, thank you.

My pleasure, Hoke. I'm happy my posts elicited such nice memories for you.

As regards rue du Cherche-Midi in the 6th arr., actually, when in Paris I prefer to stay at (and have always stayed at) hotels in the 1st arrondissement. My wife, however, for this trip chose to rent an apartment (rather than stay at a hotel) for, as I understood from her, mainly 2 reasons:

1. It would come out less expensive since the kids were with us;

2. We would, during our stay, live like Parisians rather than tourists; and,

3. Chose Cherche-Midi in the 6th because her cousins and friends like that part of town (i.e., shopping and hanging out, though they themselves have never actually stayed on that street).

Naturally, I gave in as I will try anything at least once (within bounds of reason). At the end of the day, however, next in Paris, it will be back to a hotel in the 1st arr. for us, for the following reasons:

1. The "savings" of using an apartment in such neighborhood, as opposed to a decent hotel in the 1st arr., is not really material, considering...

2. ...the convenience of staying in a hotel.*

3. Being from the Philippines, we are tourists in Paris - always have been and always will be; so I fail to see the allure of "living like Parisians".*

Don't get me wrong, I did very much enjoy the Paris leg of this trip. However, next time, I will do things a little differently.

* Being from the Philippines, we are accustomed to having maids do pretty much everything for us. That is our culture. At the risk of sounding like a "spoiled brat", I do not see the point in spending money on a vacation which would entail effort in having to do chores we do not have to do at home and are not accustomed to doing (i.e., in this particular case, buying food for breakfast, making breakfast, washing breakfast dishes, pans, cleaning the coffee machine, keeping the place tidy, etc.). In addition, once checked out of a hotel, the hotel will stow one's luggage leaving one free to enjoy the city more until one's flight home. Those conveniences, among many others (e.g., room service, the concierge making one's reservations in restaurants, etc.), are available at hotels, but not in a rented apartment.

Jenise wrote:After reading all these reports, my bags are all but packed. Thank you so much for the tour!

Bon voyage, Jenise!

Jon Peterson wrote:...and credit card limits increased ten-fold!

Hahaha, well, no vacation is free, and Paris is, naturally, a little pricey, but, that's the way it is, isn't it?

Personally, when on vacation abroad, we pay in cash as much as possible to avoid "sticker shock" when we are back home and the credit card bill comes in. During this 3-week trip, I used a credit card on only three occasions, namely: to pay for the hotel of the Champagne leg (which had to be pre-paid when I made my online booking earlier on), for the car rental (Hertz prefers it this way), and, when I had to pay for parking one time in Reims and had no change for the machine.

Diane (Long Island) wrote:And I am really trying to get a reservation via their website, and I haven't heard back.

It took them a day to respond to mine.

Best to all,

N
no avatar
User

Ted Richards

Rank

Ultra geek

Posts

436

Joined

Wed Aug 06, 2008 2:00 pm

Location

Toronto, Canada

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Ted Richards » Mon Apr 29, 2013 11:49 pm

That sounds wonderful, Noel.

I think I know where I'm going on my 65th birthday September 17! Anybody want to join us? Foie gras, duck AND Burgundy. How can you go wrong :D
no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Noel Ermitano » Tue Apr 30, 2013 12:17 am

Can't go wrong with that, for sure!

Best,

N
no avatar
User

Rahsaan

Rank

Wild and Crazy Guy

Posts

9803

Joined

Tue Mar 28, 2006 8:20 pm

Location

New York, NY

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Rahsaan » Tue Apr 30, 2013 1:49 pm

Noel Ermitano wrote:Being from the Philippines, we are accustomed to having maids do pretty much everything for us. That is our culture. At the risk of sounding like a "spoiled brat", I do not see the point in spending money on a vacation which would entail effort in having to do chores we do not have to do at home and are not accustomed to doing (i.e., in this particular case, buying food for breakfast, making breakfast, washing breakfast dishes, pans, cleaning the coffee machine, keeping the place tidy, etc.). In addition, once checked out of a hotel, the hotel will stow one's luggage leaving one free to enjoy the city more until one's flight home. Those conveniences, among many others (e.g., room service, the concierge making one's reservations in restaurants, etc.), are available at hotels, but not in a rented apartment.


Interesting set of arguments. I suppose the service aspect is uncontestable. But, for my own lifestyle I much prefer apartments because I can't imagine eating in restaurants non-stop during a trip of any more than one or two days. And for me, one of the big attractions of Paris is hanging out in farmers' markets and cheese shops and wine shops, chatting and purchasing, and then of course consuming. All of which is easier in an apartment than a hotel.

But, there's plenty for everyone in the City of Light.
no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Noel Ermitano » Wed May 01, 2013 12:41 pm

Rahsaan wrote:Interesting set of arguments....

My statements are not arguments. They are based on what I am (and my family members are) accustomed to. I am a lawyer by profession, and do not argue unless I am paid...unless I feel like arguing during my spare time - which I generally do not on wine boards.

The thought of going to the markets, buying nice stuff, cooking at the apartment, etc., did occur to me, by the way. It was the thought of cleaning up afterwards that stopped me. Cleaning up after simple breakfasts of croissants, pain chocolat, butter, confitures, hams, smoked duck breast, juice, & coffee (plus eggs for anyone who cared) was more than enough for me. What more a serious meal? My wife and children all enjoy wine as well...that means the wine glasses have to be hand-washed as well. No thanks. I don't do that at home; and having to do so is not my idea of a vacation.
no avatar
User

Sam Platt

Rank

I am Sam, Sam I am

Posts

2330

Joined

Sat Mar 25, 2006 12:22 pm

Location

Indiana, USA

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Sam Platt » Wed May 01, 2013 2:52 pm

My statements are not arguments. They are based on what I am (and my family members are) accustomed to.

Noel,

I worked with one of our plant managers as he transitioned from his native Philippines to one of our Mexican plants. One of the first things he did on moving his household to the U.S. (Mexico border) was to hire a maid and a cook. He expressed amazement that Americans were able to function without household support. Both were as much of a necessity to him as a vehicle would be to a typical American.

PS: I kept him away from my wife so that he didn’t give her any ideas! :)
Sam

"The biggest problem most people have is that they think they shouldn't have any." - Tony Robbins
no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Re: Lunch @ La Tour d'Argent, Paris.

by Noel Ermitano » Wed May 08, 2013 10:37 am

Hi, Sam. Yes, it is just a matter of one's particular circumstances is all. Here, househelp is commonplace. Yes, I do believe keeping your friend from bringing up with your wife is probably a good move. My brother's wife is Japanese; born and raised in Tokyo (though she took her college in the USA), she moved to our country when they married. Having live-in househelp is uncommon in Tokyo, so, very understandably, she wasn't all that comfortable with the idea of having maids - that is, until after a little while when she got used to it. Now, she can't imagine living without househelp.

Best,

N

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: ClaudeBot, FB-extagent, Google Adsense [Bot] and 1 guest

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign