What a treat it was to meet WLDGers Bruce Hayes and Clint Hall as well as their lovely wives. I feel awful that we have lived so close to the Halls for these eight years but had not met until now. Glad that's changed.
1999 Charles Ellner Brut Champagne – Good bubbly! The touch of residual sweetness in this charming bubbly made a great pairing with the amuse bouche of seared scalled with bruleed grapefruit. And the sommelier chose wisely when he followed that with:
2009 Delille Chaleur Estate – This was Clint's bottle, but I bought this wine about a year ago and drank a bottle immediately upon acquisition, and remember it as being tightly wound and lemon-steely. The extent to which the semillon now runs the show was quite a surprise. Straw-colored, with lemon oil, beeswax and a bit of slate on the palate. Very dry finish.
With fresh lobster salad:
2009 Buty White – I'm so glad Clint brought this, as IMO it's one of Washington's best whites. Expertly blended, it has an effusive nose with sweet white flowers that lightens the opening but there's also some determined fresh lemon on the palate, making it a refreshing sipper but also an excellent food wine. I'm a fan of both wines but agree that this showed better last night.
2005 St. Innocent Freedom Hill Chardonnay – I brought this thinking that St. Innocent would be a name Bruce would see a lot of here on WLDG but would probably have not tasted. I vacillated between whether to bring a pinot or a chardonnay, finally deciding that though the pinot could not fail to impress, perhaps an aged Burgundian style west coast chardonnay would do even more. Can't improve on your description, Bill.
With wild mushroom and spinach ravioli in a garlic cream sauce:
2004 Copain Pinot Noir Cerise Vd. (Anderson Valley) – My wine again. I have both the 02 and 04 of this wine and actually grabbed the 02 first, but recent reports on Cellar Tracker suggest that the 02 needs more time and the 04 is in the moment. They were certainly right about the 04. Big aromatics on the nose on sweet pinot fruit with good body that made it the favorite of some, but like you I found the heat marred the finish. I preferred David and Nadine's:
2001 Arcadian Gary’s Vd. Pinot Noir – Garys' Vineyard (not to be pedantic, but I think you'd want to know that it IS Garys'--this vineyard is jointly owned by two guys named Gary) is IMO one of California's best pinot vineyards, and Joe Davis at Arcadian is one of California's best pinot noir makers. All the reasons for both were evident in this wine: red fruit with sweet, warm cherry pie fruit up front, spices in the middle and iron-rich earthy elements completing the picture. Outstanding.
With roasted rack of Salt Spring Island lamb on potato-carrot gratin:
1991 Dunn Napa Cabernet – can't improve on your description but would add graphite.
1995 Viader Cabernet (Napa) – Surprisingly sweet after the Dunn, which I had a hard time adjusting to. Youthful fruit with very resolved tannins.
2001 Leonetti Cabernet – blackberry and espresso with just a hint of soy, and a very nice representative from Washington. Very very very different than the bottle of 01 we opened about two years ago, which was lighter red with unusually mature fruit. Glad to know that our bottle was a fluke, though since it was an orphan I don't know what I'm going to do with this information.
1990 Mondavi Reserve Cabernet – Loved this ghost of Mondavi past--I'd almost forgotten that classic tangy, spicy Mondavi nose. Ole Bob would be proud of how well this showed last night.
1992 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet – But the most perfect bottle in the cabernet flight was this wine. A tangy blend of boysenberry, blackberry and plum fruit with cocoa dust and spice and that long sweet finish. I can't believe you've had this in your cellar for nearly 20 years and are only JUST opening your first bottle. Excellent.
Wiith the cheese plates:
2000 Carmenet Copa de Oro Late Harvest Semillon – I brought this wine because between Clint, Bill, David/Nadine and I, this was the only west coast stickie in any of our cellars! It's just not a forte out here, and there are better wines at better prices from Europe and elsewhere. Deep orange color bordering on tawny, with hazelnuts, tangerine and a bit of burnt caramel. Good acidity kept it from being cloying on the palate. Good. Blind, no one would have guessed the grape.