by Jenise » Sun Feb 13, 2011 4:58 pm
2006 Scholium Project Farina Vineyards “The Prince in his Caves” – My wine. Grassy nose that I only belatedly identified as grassy--at first, it was more cactusy with passion fruit, honey and a bit of coconut on the nose that did not prepare one for the peachy, bone dry palate. Fascinating wine--thanks to David Bueker, Oswaldo and everyone else who talked up these idiosyncratic wines enough to make me understand that my life would not be complete without at least one Scholium experience. To put that in perspective, I'll note that I paid about $50 for this bottle and thought the wine well worth it.
2000 Tyrells Vat 47 Hunter Valley Chardonnay – this has a very interesting and beguiling scent on the nose that I couldn't relate to any fruit I know except to say that it was both exotic and seductive. Excellent, though I would not hold longer.
2002 Le Logis de la Bouchardiere Chinon Le Clos – Bill, I'm with you, did not recognize this as cab franc. Initial nose of powdered cherry fruit and tobacco laced with a hormonal blast of vitamin B on the palate did not ring familiar. Adequate acids, resolved tannins. No previous acquaintaince with this producer, but the wine was quite good. Would drink up any remaining bottles soon though.
1985 William Hill Cabernet Sauvignon Silver Label (Napa) - Can't improve on your assessment, Bill.
2000 Malvira Roero Mombeltrano - Delicious, and it certainly rang Italian but nebbiolo was about the last grape I suspected.
2000 Livon Tiare Mate Merlot – My notes say: "open, generous sweetness, possible mild oak, Bordeauxish. Right bank Merlot?" but my verbalization must have been faint as it's owner never heard me and the questioning went on. Very interesting wine.
2001 Fattoria Barbi Brunello – What you said.
2003 Ch. Pontet Canet – Plums, black cherry and cigar box, classicly Paulliac. I get that part, Coop goes in for the kill guessing Pontet Canet. A rare example, in my experience, of a 2003 that doesn't taste Californian. Excellent.
Ch. d’Orignac Pineau des Charentes – I loved this thing. Smokey pink color. Lychee syrup nose, watermelon palate with a hint of dried nectarine tang, and fantastic (how wierd is this) following the grapefruit segments on my fruit plate. I rarely finish the dessert wines but I didn't leave a drop of this behind.
1990 Quady Starboard Franks Vineyard – Hmmm...I definitely mistook it for port. It was certainly tighter and more en pointe than the Starboard Jimmy brought last month which was very easily identifiable as new world/simple/Californian. Very good.
My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov