The place for all things wine, focused on serious wine discussions.

Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by Noel Ermitano » Tue May 18, 2010 5:06 am

Two days after Catha and I returned from Spain, on the 10th April 2010, we were 2 of the fortunate 10 to be treated by Tita Bella to her lavish, modern Chinese banquet at her place. Aside from our ever-svelte and gracious hostess (who joined us in a few of the many elaborate courses she herself prepared), in attendance were Rene & Aimee, Miguel & Ria, Jojo & Fides, J-Lab & Jocel, Catha & I.

Image
Ria, Aimee & Miguel

We were the last couple to arrive, I recall. The others had already polished off a white and were working on a bubbly when we got there.

Image
J-Lab, Jocel & Catha

Image
Jojo & Rene

Image

2007 Coldstream Hills Sparkling Wine - From Australia's Yarra Valley, the label says it is a blend of chardonnay and pinot noir and, to me, it tastes like it is mostly chardonnay. Simple, straightforward, penetrating, linear green apple and citrus quickly lead the way until some leesy, mildly creamy roundness and marginal heft (from the pinot noir most likely) present at mid-palate. Rather over-eager yeastiness kicks in past mid mouth and trails with a rather sharp citrus finish. A bit too tightly wound now and the citrus notes border on shrill. It's a good enough summer quaffer, I suppose, but it's not really something I'd personally go for - not at this point anyway.

We eventually were called for dinner proper, so eagerly seated ourselves for the evening's delights.

The Menu

Image

Image
Rene pours for Catha & Fides...

Image
...and the first course is served.

Image

Fried Milk with Kani& Apricot Marmalade - a delectable spin on an old favorite in Hong Kong. The crab and apricot marmalade gave a novel (to me) and playful twist to an old, familiar dish that we usually have at the end of a dim sum lunch. Tita Bella's take on this, however, turns it into a good starting course - in the style of a seared foie gras with a fruity glaze. I had this with a sip of...

Image

Billecart-Salmon Brut Blanc de Blancs NV - Jojo's bottle. Their non-vintages consistently show good depth, mid-palate heft, pleasing roundness as well as freshness of fruit. This showed hallmark green apple and citrus brightness and, just past mid-mouth, elegant brioche notes. The apricot glaze clashed with this, so I reserved the rest of my glass for the next dish.

Image
Boiling Sharksfin Soup with Shredded Crabmeat

Image

I love sharks' fin soup. This, to me, was a unique version, more concentrated and heartier than most all I've tried before and with a deep, permeating caramelized earthiness in the soup's base. With the accompanying Chinese vinegar to give a bit of cut, I just couldn't stop from greedily slurping this up and couldn't help help myself from asking for a second helping. Greenies and pro-shark bleeding hearts be damned - I'd have this everyday if I could. They are welcome to try and stop me if they can.

The blanc de blancs was a good enough pairing. In my experience, with other sharks fin soups, I prefer pinot noir dominated champagnes; with Tita Bella's version, however, the bright edge of this blanc de blancs gave needed cut and lift. I'm getting hungry again just thinking about it.

The next dish was another unique one, a house specialty of Tita Bella: Spicy Beef on Chinese Spaghetti Noodles, Sliced Cucumber. How lucky her children are to have grown up with such creative dishes by their mom.

Image
Aimee demonstrates how to serve and eat this unique dish...

Image
...and Miguel quickly attacks as Jojo looks on.

Image

This Spicy Beef on Chinese Spaghetti Noodles with Sliced Cucumber, I understand, is also a favorite of Santi who requests it even at continental menus of Tita Bella. I now see why. I recall Jojo and Miguel, among others, getting subsequent helpings. I love how the sliced cucumber on top gives freshness and lift to this. Excellent touch. With this was paired...

Image

2004 Ravenswood Old Hill Zinfandel - J-Lab's bottle. I've actually visited this winery in Sonoma Valley with some old friends back in May 2001 and tasted a few of their powerfully alcoholic zinfandels. Honestly, I couldn't see the allure. Getting kicked in the head I somehow find unappealing. This, however, was more rounded and markedly more civilized in its deeper, denser, blackberry, blueberry, dark red berry, slight black pepper, whispers of toffee/cinnamon/nutmeg and somber, underlying dark mineral notes with a bit of loam. Nice enough in itself, and it did go fairly well with the dish. I, myself, was absolutely stumped on how to pair the dish, so kudos to J-Lab for taking a brave stab at the pairing.

Image

With the Roasted Peking Duck, Lotus Wrappers & Hoisin Sauce, two German rieslings were served:

Image

2003 Dönnhoff Oberhäuser Brücke Riesling Auslese (Goldkapsule) - My bottle. An auslese (late harvest) from a very ripe vintage, it, nonetheless, displayed good enough acidity in its vaguely tropical-charactered (not baked) notes of honeyed ripe pear, peach, apricot, honeysuckle with light touches of spice, petrol (topnote) and slate (underlying on the palate). Elegant acid balance lent the more-rounded-and-riper-than-usual fruit precise lift and cut. Perfect with the Peking Duck as I had planned. I loved this riesling and most of the ladies did too (though I recall Miguel, Tita Bella and Aimee preferring the next one).

Image

Image

Image

2005 Joh.Jos.Prum Graacher Himmelreich Riesling Spätlese - Jojo's bottle, with an impressive name ("Himmelreich" = Kingdom of Heaven" or "Sky Kingdom"). As a younger spätlese, though also from a particularly ripe year, this showed lighter, more enthusiastic playfulness, like it was twirling about on the palate. It was also, of course, marginally less sweet. Its peach, pear and apple notes showed very good purity and a nice, steely, bright minerally backbone. Healthy acidity lends remarkable freshness and the youthful spritziness just adds to its happy dance. Very nice indeed. I'd say this is more versatile a wine (can easily and happily be sipped alone) than the previous bottle, but, as a pairing with Tita Bella's Peking Duck, the latter's added heft and sweetness gave it the edge for me.

Image
What have we here now...?

Image
Steamed Crab Legs with Garlic, Vermicelli & Soya Dressing, paired with...

Image

2008 Caymus Conundrum Proprietary Blend - Rene's bottle, I recall having Conundrum only twice before and both times from Rocky and Apple, once each at their Sugar Loaf and Hillsborough residences (no written notes, I'm afraid since I was sipping them while cooking both times). Rather heavy and fat after the two German rieslings, it came off as too heavy, fat, baked and oaky for me. The fruits were a mélange of baked lemon cream, melon, apple, yellow apricot, some grassiness, lime, white grapefruit and a bucket of oak/vanilla. Acidity was low; purity and focus didn't seem to be a consideration. I understand it is so named to befuddle the taster in guessing the cepages, but, for me, I see no point in it. Not my type, though I can understand why new world palates would enjoy this. To each his own, but this is not for me.

That it was served with a steamed shellfish dish just seemed to emphasize its oaky, low acid, baked, flabby nature. It probably would have done better with a richer, heavier dish. I could see this doing well with roast porkloin.

Image
Crispy Pork Wedges Glazed with Sweet Sour Sauce (photo by Miguel)

Wow. Honestly, I stopped ordering sweet and sour pork many years ago. This one, however, was special, unlike the ubiquitous, overly fatty, usually soggy and boring ones one comes across most any Chinese restaurant. This was actually crisp and the glaze, though, indeed, spicily-sweet, had an uncommon depth to it. The only local version that comes close to this was the one at the old Gloriamaris at the Manila Bay when it was being run by Tita Glenda Barretto when I was still in college. It was a hit. I got three moderate servings...

Image
...while Jojo happily got much more.

Image
Photo by Miguel

1990 Château Sociando-Mallet - Jojo's bottle. I've had this at least twice or thrice before as I vaguely recall; the last time being at a Chinese lunch in early September 2009, during which he sponsored most all the wines. This subject bottle, I drank from alone, after the glazed crispy pork wedges. Consistent with my last notes, I reproduce them hereunder:

Warming, complex and deep, the ripe black and red fruit (easily riper than the '96) melded seamlessly with notes of cedar, violets, nuances of mushroom, leather with whispers of meat, pencil shavings and licorice. Just a shade under full-bodied, good concentration. Very nice indeed.

We then moved on to two dessert courses...

Image
Chilled Almond Jelly, and...

Image
Tikoy Surprise.

As one can easily see from the photos, Tita Bella cast her creative spells on both typical, well-known Chinese dessert/snack dishes: bringing the otherwise ubiquitous chilled almond jelly with lychees to loftier heights by adding in kiwi and other in-season, summer fruits; and, transforming the tikoy into crispy-flaky outside/warm and softly chewy inside, turón-reminiscent cylinders of goodness. She really leaves no stone unturned, ever.

Image

Many, many thanks again to our most generous and talented hostess. Your dishes never cease to amaze. I don't know how you do it, but we're all certainly glad that you can and do.
no avatar
User

David M. Bueker

Rank

Childless Cat Dad

Posts

36363

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 11:52 am

Location

Connecticut

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by David M. Bueker » Tue May 18, 2010 7:08 am

Fabulous!

It's interesting to see your take on Ravenswood, as they have often been criticized for not being gutsy enough for the currently in vogue style of California Zinfandel. I was a regular buyer in the '90s, but I have not tried a recent vintage in quite a long time.

Loved the Brucke and Himelreich notes. I opened a '99 Prum Himmelreich Spatlese over the weekend, and while it really could have used more cellar time, it was still very good.
Decisions are made by those who show up
no avatar
User

Noel Ermitano

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

850

Joined

Mon Sep 10, 2007 2:28 am

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by Noel Ermitano » Tue May 18, 2010 7:32 am

David M. Bueker wrote:It's interesting to see your take on Ravenswood, as they have often been criticized for not being gutsy enough for the currently in vogue style of California Zinfandel. I was a regular buyer in the '90s, but I have not tried a recent vintage in quite a long time.

I really do not drink any zinfandel, tried some before but never really liked any. It was at table, so I gave it a taste and was pleasantly surprised. It's not something I'd ever seek out or buy if I came across it (same could be said of any zinfandel), but it was nice enough.

What is "the currently in vogue style of California Zinfandel", by the way?

Loved the Brucke and Himelreich notes. I opened a '99 Prum Himmelreich Spatlese over the weekend, and while it really could have used more cellar time, it was still very good.

Thanks, I also brought a 2002 Ostertag Zellenberg Pinot Gris to pair with the Peking duck, but the others said 2 rieslings for the dish would be enough, so my bottle was saved for a subsequent duck.

Re: the Prüm's youth, it is nice to test these things and follow them as they age. The fellow who brought it has an over 11,000 premium (and I do mean all top of the line) bottle collection. He has many of these to age and monitor as the years pass. The fellow is certifiably mad. He never stops buying. It's a sickness.

N
no avatar
User

David M. Bueker

Rank

Childless Cat Dad

Posts

36363

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 11:52 am

Location

Connecticut

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by David M. Bueker » Tue May 18, 2010 7:47 am

The current style of California Zinfandel is similar or slightly higher (or even much higher) levels of alcohol than the Ravenswood wines, and with even more ripeness and thickness (to my palate) to the fruit/mouthfeel. I find the style generally unpleasant, but not everyone is doing it. Producers like Ridge, Dashe and a few others have successfully resisted.

As far as driking Prum young, I either do it in the first year or two, or wait for year 10. Of course at 10 the wines are still very young.

As for the 11,000 bottle cellar; I can only dream.
Decisions are made by those who show up
no avatar
User

John S

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

1180

Joined

Thu Jun 22, 2006 2:12 am

Location

British Columbia

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by John S » Tue May 18, 2010 3:43 pm

Damn, I'm so hungry after seeing all those dishes! Lovely pics and notes on what looked like a great dinner.

I've never had shark fin soup, and admit I'm one of those who would never order it - the sharks are being relentlessly slaughtered in all the oceans, and I don't want to be a direct part of that - but I have to admit, it looked delicious!

OK, I've got to go for lunch now!
no avatar
User

ChaimShraga

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

663

Joined

Fri Oct 03, 2008 4:53 am

Location

Tel-Aviv, Israel

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by ChaimShraga » Tue May 18, 2010 4:04 pm

Holy cow, a great dinner and a great post!
Positive Discrimination For White Wines!
http://2GrandCru.blogspot.com
no avatar
User

AlexR

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

806

Joined

Fri Mar 31, 2006 9:28 am

Location

Bordeaux

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by AlexR » Thu May 20, 2010 3:48 pm

Noel,

Thanks again for sharing with us.

The spirit of your get-togethers - one knows intuitively - is to enjoy very special food and wine, but in a FUN - as opposed to an academic or snooty -way.

Your pictures and reports of dinners are a real treat!!!!

All the best,
Alex
no avatar
User

Tom N.

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

797

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 10:17 pm

Location

Soo, Ont.

Re: Bubblies, Rieslings, Bdx Rouge, Etc. w/ Chinese Dinner.

by Tom N. » Thu May 20, 2010 10:34 pm

David M. Bueker wrote:The current style of California Zinfandel is similar or slightly higher (or even much higher) levels of alcohol than the Ravenswood wines, and with even more ripeness and thickness (to my palate) to the fruit/mouthfeel. I find the style generally unpleasant, but not everyone is doing it. Producers like Ridge, Dashe and a few others have successfully resisted.

David,

I have one bottle of that style left from our California trip - a Turley 2006 Old Vines Zin. I have sort of an eclectic palate for these types of wines with my tastes going to both ends of the spectrum depending on my wine mood at the time, but while tasting at Turley in Paso Robles, the last Zin (Dusi vineyard 2006 - 16.4% abv) I tried was too much for me with the alcoholic heat on the finish pushing it over the top even for my palate.

Noel,

Thanks! What a great dinner and tasting notes 8) . I would have loved to enjoyed such an excellent repast.
Tom Noland
Good sense is not common.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Apple Bot, ClaudeBot, Ripe Bot and 0 guests

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign