Thursday (3/25)
After a leasurely coffee w/ Casey and a retaste thru the Eaglepoint Syrah Cage Match wines,
we head on down from Eaglepoint in irregular drizzle w/ occasional patches of sunshine to Sebastapol.
Several months ago, BobLindquist was talking w/ RickMorrison (his marketing guy) about the need to
get the word out about the other kind/non-Parker non-98-pt Syrahs like he makes. From this seminal
idea grew the idea of today's Syrah seminar on "A Question of Balance". DanFredman helped greatly
in the spadework for this event.
The seminar was to focus w/ Syrahs made w/ elegance/balance/restraint. The winemakers/wines shown
at the event were chosen to be representative of such wines. It was a very casual gathering, sort of
a sitting down amongst friends and talking thru the subject. The idea was to make this sort of a test-drive
of a seminar that they'd like to take on the road. It would make an ideal seminar for RhoneRangers or
HospicesDuRhone.
Much of the invitees were supposed to be from the media. Alas, a lot of them bailed at the last minute
and the attendance was a bit on the sparse side. Susan & I were only a handful of non-media there.
Also there was PatrickComisky (LATimes), JordanMcKay (SF-based writer), LindaMurphy (SFChron), DanBerger
(StaRosaPress-Democrat) and a few others I recognized but couldn't come up w/ names.
The event was held at SteveSinger's PizzaVino restaurant in Sebastapol. After the seminar, we were
treated to two different wood-fired pizzas and cesear salad, all very wonderfully done. It's definitely
a restaurant I'd like to revisit next time.
The panel consisted of PatrickWill/Guigal, StevenSinger/BakerLane, KevinClancey/EdmundsStJohn,BobLindquist/
Qupe, WellsGuthrie/Copain, RajParr (ParrSelections), DuncanMeyer&NathanRoberts/Arnot-Roberts,
and JasonDrew/DrewFamily. SteveEdmunds was on his way back from NewYork and Wells had just returned from
a marketing trip and was sicker'n a dog.
Bob gave a sort of introduction/explanation of the event & turned it over to moderator PatrickWill,
who expanded on Bob's ideas and made the introductions. Mostly, the winemakers focused on the details
and origins of their wines, with alcohol levels and point-scores not being mentioned at all.
The wines and my notes:
1. Guigal HermitageRouge 2005: Dark color; earthy/smokey some blackberry/Syrah light roasted rather Calif
Syrah nose; tart bit lean/hard some blackberry/Syrah bit earthy/dusty little roasted/NorthernRhone light
oak flavor; med.long some blackberry/Syrah very slight roasted finish w/ fair tannins; needs 5-10 yrs
of age; not a lot of NorthernRhone/roasted character and rather Calif in style.
_______________________
2. Guigal Cote-Rotie Ch. D'Ampuis 2005: Med.color; rather floral/violets light roasted/espresso/Rhonish bit
toasty/oak some complex/smokey nose; tart rather hard/lean light smokey/pungent/oak some Calif/blackberry/
Syrah slight roasted/espresso/Rhonish light floral/violets flavor; med.long rather hard/tannic/lean
light smokey/roasted/Rhonish/espresso light toasty/oak light floral finish; needs more age; more Rhonish
in character but rather Calif-like and not strongly C-R/roasted.
_______________________
3. BakerLane Estate Syrah 2007: Dark color; bright/forward/blackberry/Syrah rather smokey/pungent/pencilly/
oak slight cracked pepper very attractive/forward nose; softer/lusher bright blackberry/Syrah light
pungent/pencilly/oak bit tannic/hard flavor; long bright/lush/blackberry/Syrah light pungent/oak slight
cracked pepper finish w/ some hard tannins; needs several yrs yet; a solid 4-square blackberry Syrah.
_______________________
4. BakerLane Estate Syrah 2006: Dark color; strong blackberry/Syrah quite peppery/spicy/cracked black pepper/
cold climate complex nose; tarter strong blackberry/blueberry/Syrah strong cracked black pepper/cold-
climate somewhat hard/tannic flavor; very long strong blackberry/Syrah some cracked black pepper finish w/
some tannins; needs several yrs yet; more cold-climate/cracked pepper character than the '07; quite a good/
interesting cold-climate Syrah.
_______________________
5. EdmundsStJohn Syrah CuveeFairbairn/MendocinoCnty 2008: Med.dark color; strong blackberry/Syrah/spicy light
earthy/dusty bit perfumed somewhat simple nose; tart bit lean/hard spicy/blackberry/Syrah bit simple
flavor; med.long blackberry/Syrah light spicy/earthy finish w/ some tannins; a pleasant enough Syrah but
a bit on the simple side and not that distinctive; may age into something interesting given Steve's
wine's track record.
_______________________
6. EdmundsStJohn Syrah BassettiVnyd/SLOCnty 2005: Very dark color; very strong blackberry/blueberry/Syrah
very spicy/slight cracked pepper quite perfumed/aromatic nose; tart very spicy blueberry/blackberry/
Syrah slight herbal/dusty slight smokey/roasted somewhat tannic flavor; very long intense blueberry/
blackberry/Syrah some herbal/peppery slight floral/violets finish w/ fair tannins; seems more PasoSyrah
and less cold-climate Syrah than before; very interesting Syrah.
_______________________
7. Qupe Syrah CentralCoast 2008: Med.color; strong blackberry/Syrah slight minerally/milk of magnesia bit
smokey/pungent slight Rhonish interesting nose; tart very spicy/blackberry/Syrah slight smokey/pungent/
ersatz-Rhonish flavor w/ light tannins; med.long tart strong blackberry/Syrah slight smokey/Rhonish finish
w/ modest tannins; no signs of brett like in the '07 here; one of the better QupeCC Syrahs in a number
of yrs; nicely done slightly Rhonish Syrah at a good price.
_______________________
8. Qupe Syrah BienNacidoHillsideEstate 2006: Dark color; strong blackberry/Syrah slight roasted/Rhonish
slight appley/spicy somewhat smokey/pungent perfumed nose; tart bit smokey/pungent/Rhonish strong
blackberry/plummy/boysenberry/Syrah/blueberry slight Rhonish/roasted flavor; long plummy/blueberry/
blackberry/Syrah light smokey/pungent/Rhonish finish w/ light tannins; not particularly big/intense but
great balance that should take it out 10-15 yrs; very nice pungent/Rhonish character.
_______________________
9. Copain Syrah BakerRanch/AndersonVlly 2007: Med.dark color; strong pungent/Rhonish/roasted/coffee/smokey
spicy/blueberry/blackberry/Syrah slight peppery/cold-climate complex nose; tart bit lean/tight some
Rhonish/peppery/cold-climate strong blueberry/Syrah/blackberry bit smokey/pungent flavor w/ modest tannins;
very long/lingering Rhonish/roasted/espresso/smokey strong blueberry/Syrah finish; still needs several yrs;
lots of cold-climate/Rhonish character.
_______________________
10. Copain Syrah Hawk'sButte/YorkvilleHighlands 2007: Med.dark color; stronger blackberry/blueberry/Syrah
some roasted/pungent/Rhonish complex nose; tart somewhat richer/lusher/blackberry/Syrah some roasted/
espresso/smokey some tannic flavor; med.long lush/rich tart blackberry/Syrah roasted/Rhonish finish w/
modest tannins; needs several yrs yet; more upfront lush Syrah fruit and less cold-climate character.
_______________________
11. ParrSelections SantaYnezVlly Syrah Anika (sans-soufre; 13.9%) 2007: Dark color; some roasted/cold-climate/
peppery strong blackberry/Syrah light toasty/oak nose; tart bit thin/lean peppery/blackberry/blueberry/
Syrah very attractive flavor; long tart bit tight/lean peppery/blackberry/Syrah light toasty/oak finish;
needs several yrs; seems a bit leaner/tighter, a bit more aromatic than the PurisimaMtn.
_______________________
12. ParrSelections Syrah PurisimaMtn/SantaYnezVlly 2007: Very dark color; very strong blackberry/Syrah/
blueberry ripe/lush light toasty/oak nose; softer/lusher/riper very strong blackberry/Syrah light toasty/
pungent/oak some spicy/floral/violets flavor; long strong/blackberry/Syrah/ripe/lush light toasty/oak
finish w/ some tannins; needs some age yet; seems riper & lusher than the Anika.
_______________________
13. Arnot-Roberts Syrah ClaryRanch/PetalumaGap/SonomaCoast 2007: Beautiful Rhonish/roasted/espresso floral/
violets some blackberry/blueberry/Syrah complex very Cote-Rotie-like nose; tart bit hard/tannic very strong
roasted/Rhonish/pungent/espresso/bacon fat/smokey strong blueberry/blackberry/Syrah/violets complex flavor;
very long/lingering very Rhonish/roasted/espresso/bacon fat/pungent rather hard/tannic very strong Syrah/
blackberry/blueberry complex finish; huge NorthernRhone character; my favorite wine of the tableau.
_______________________
14. Arnot-Roberts Syrah HudsonVnyd/Carneros 2008: Dark color; rich/blackberry/Syrah/boysenberry/quite spicy
some toasted/roasted lovely nose w/ less cold-climate/peppery character than the Clary; tart rather lush/
ripe/blackberry/Syrah almost simple some toasty/smokey/oak flavor w/ less obvious tannins; long fairly
lush/ripe/blackberry/Syrah slight toasty/oak slight Rhonish/roasted finish w/ some tannins; doesn't show
the cold-climate Syrah character that Hudson often does; seems more rich & lush & less Rhonish.
_______________________
15. DrewFamily Syrah PerliRanch/MendocinoRidge 2007: Beautiful floral/violets very perfumed/aromatic strong
blackberry/Syrah slight licorice/pungent/tarry nose; tart fairly rich strong blackberrry/blueberry/Syrah
light toasty/oak slight licorice/pungent flavor w/ some tannins; long lush/blackberry/Syrah very aromatic/
perfumed almost Pinotish fragrant light toasty/oak finish w/ some tannins; seems riper & lusher than
the Valenti.
_______________________
16. DrewFamily Syrah ValentiVnyd/AndersonVlly/MendocinoRidge 2007: Lovely very perfumed/aromatic strong Syrah/
blackberry/blueberry some cold-climate/cracked black pepper bit Rhonish/roasted/coffee/espresso light
toasty/oak complex nose; tart some peppery/cold-climate strong blueberry/Syrah slight Rhonish/roasted
flavor w/ modest tannins; fairly tart peppery/cold-climate strong blueberry/Syrah quite aromatic/perfumed/
floral light toasty/oak finish w/ modest tannins; may favorite of the two because of the cold-climate
a slightly Rhonish character. A lovely AndersonVlly Syrah.
_______________________
17. EdmundsStJohn Syrah BassettiVnyd/SLOCnty 2001: Med.dark color; beautiful floral/violets strong blueberry/
Syrah slight herbal/earthy/peppery somewhat unclean/bretty almost SouthernRhone nose; tart floral/violets/
blackberry/Syrah slight herbal/peppery/cold-climate some Rhonish/espresso some brett/unclean flavor w/
some tannins; very long/lingering peppery/herbal/blueberry/Syrah light floral/violets some unclean/bretty
finish w/ some tannins; still going strong and should continue to develop; brett a bit stronger/distracting
then I'd like, but plenty of stuff going on in this wine.
_______________________
18. Qupe Syrah 20'thAnniv/BienNacidp/X-Block 2001: Very dark color; strong toasty/smokey/charred/oak/Francois
Freres strong blackberry/Syrah/blueberry rather complex rather Rhonish nose; tart rather tannic strong
smokey/oak/charred/pungent some roasted/Rhonish strong blackberry/blueberry/Syrah bit complex flavor; very
long/lingering strong smokey/charred/oak some pungent/roasted/Rhonish/espresso strong blackberry/Syrah
finish w/ fair tannins; still needs more time. Developing very lovely and will continue its upward
trajectory.
____________________________________________________________________________________________
And a wee BloodyPulpit:
1. Guigal: These wines were an interesting juxtaposition to the Calif Syrahs. I have long found Hermitage
wines more Calif in style than NorthernRhone/C-R in style, with much less of that roasted/espresso
character that makes C-R so special. The Ch.D'Ampuis did not have the strong roasted/espresso character
that I find in their Brune&Blonde and that is somewhat covered by new oak/extraction of the LaLa's,
which I regard as great C-R made in a Calif style. They both seemed ratherr tart&lean compared w/ their
Calif counterparts, but should age well I think.
_______________________
2. BakerLane: I had tried one (2005?) BakerLane Syrah early on and liked it OK but not overly impressed.
These two Estate Syrahs I was mightly impressed by, especially the 2006, for its cold-climate character.
The Estate is a few miles SouthWest of Sebastapol in the RussianRiver AVA, but true SonomaCoast.
_______________________
3. EdmundsStJohn: This was my first chance to try Steve's new Fairbairn Syrah. This comes from the Fairbairn
Ranch in MendoCnty. Originally planted by one of the Fetzer kids, it is BioDynamically farmed and goes
into the Patianna wines. Steve wanted to see if BioDynamic grapes had anything special to say. My
conclusion from this one data point would be "no". The wine seemed to be a bit on the simple side and
have nothing special or distinctive to say. That said, I had a sense, and the confidence in Steve's
winemaking ability to turn a sow's ear into a silk purse, that this wine, like his R&G, may turn into
a pretty interesting wine w/ a few yr's age. Maybe not a profound Syrah, but should provide very good
drinking over the next few yrs.
_______________________
4. Qupe: I've followed Bob's CentralCoast Syrah from the very start, the '82. It has long been a favorite
of mine and often my restaurant go-to order. The '07 that's currently on the market developed a bit too
much brett for my taste and I've not cared for the way it's evolved. Just a bit too unclean for me.
However, this about-to-be-released '08 is packed w/ Syrah fruit, clean as a whistle, and maybe one
of his best CC Syrahs in some yrs. It comes from BienNacido, FrenchCamp/Paso, Sawyer-Lindquist/EdnaVlly,
and a bit of Hillside/Block-X grapes. It's a bargin at $16 or less and promises to offer up fine drinking
for another 5-10 yrs I suspect.
I was hoping to taste his Sawyer-Lindquist Grenache and Syrah from their new EdnaVlly estate across
the road from JohnAlban at RR. Alas, the label approval had not come thru and I'll have to wait until
HdR to try it.
The X-Block comes from the oldest Syrah planting in BienNacido, that was Riesling or Chard that was
grafted over to Syrah in the early '80's at Bob's behest. Bob has stated to me that he thinks the X-Block
makes his best Syrah but, with vine maturity, the Hillside will eventually overtake it in quality. I'm
not so sure, from my limited data, that I'd agree. I've always liked the Hillside the best of Bob's
Syrahs and view it has one of Cali's greatest Syrahs and a definite ager.
_______________________
5. Parr: His sans-soufre Anika is only identified as SantaYnezVlly. I would presume it is also made from
PurisimaMtn grapes and is essentially the same wine, but w/o SO2 additions, in the style of TierryAllemand.
The differences between the two wines were distinctive, but not dramatic. It will be interesting to see
how they evolve differently w/ age.
_______________________
6. Arnot-Roberts: Every time I taste these guy's wines, I kick myself for not following their wines more
closely. Whatta doofus I am. I am quite impressed w/ the strong Rhone character they manage to get into
their wines. Better NorthernRhone than many NorthernRhone wines I try these days.
The ClaryRanch is out on the western end of the PetalumaGap, near the Pacific, and one of the coldest
Syrah plantings in Calif. Definitely pushing the boundary for Syrah. In 2009, the Syrah got only a little
above 18Brix, so it got a bit of assistance to make it into a wine. Still, Duncan thinks it tastes like
very tart cranberry juice and probably won't release it on its own.
_______________________
7. Rhonish: It never ceases to amaze me how some of the Calif Syrahs manage to achieve that special roasted/
espresso/NorthernRhone/Cote-Rotie character in their wines. Like the Neyers CuveeHonorre, Arnot-Roberts,
Copain, WindGap. Since the Calif terroir is much more different, I assume this Rhone terroir in those
wines comes from some unknown combination of oak treatment and cold-climate growing conditions. However
they do it...it's magic. In fact, as many NorthernRhones move in style towards their Calif brethern in
order to garner big scores from the wine critics; I'm finding some Calif Rhones are more NorthernRhone
in character than those guys across the ocean.
_______________________
8. Drew: I have, of course, followed Jason&Molly Drew from the very start, when I encountered the first wines
down in SantaBarbara. I've always liked his Syrah because they struck me as a Syrah made by a Pinot
producer, which he is. Not about power and extract, maybe even made w/ "balance". I was quite excited when
he pulled up roots down in SantaBarbara and moved back home to MendoCnty. He's a certifiably "great" Calif
winemaker and I have been very interested how is style translates from SantaBarbara to Mendo. His Syrahs
seem a bit even more refined/elegant than what he did down South. Well below the radar is the Albarino
he makes from AndersonVlly grapes; one of the best in Calif. What I'd really love to see is what he can
do w/ Mendo Zin. Maybe even an Eaglepoint Zin, as well as an Eaglepoint Syrah. And maybe even PetiteSirah.
And....maybe...even an Eaglepoint...Sangiovese. The possibilities boggle the mind!!
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Susan&I had the privledge of sitting by SteveAlden, owner of PerliVnyd on the MendocinoRidge. We had hoped
to make a visit w/ Steve that morning, but the weather and this seminar precluded those plans. Next visit,
I'm going to make sure I visit MendoRidge to get a better feel for the area.
One of the recurring themes the panelists brought up was for Syrah to be made w/ elegance & balance
(read less alcohol), it was necessary to grow the grapes in a cooler area, so they could achieve phenolic
ripeness, yet w/o very high sugar levels. Is this really the case?? I'm not so sure that it is. I thought
the Parr Anika showed such character, but I'd hardly call PurisimaMtn cold-climate. And certainly the
counter-case can be made. Wines w/ high alcohol and high level of extraction are made by JohnAlban, hardly
what I'd call balance. Yet his EdnaVlly Syrah is verifiably cold-climate. It will be interesting to see
what kind of Syrah comes off the Sawyer-Lindquist vnyd, grown right across the road from JohnAlban. The
original Qupe PasoRobles/EstrellaRiver Syrah '82 was more about balance and not about extraction (as were all
four of those first great Syrahs in '82). It was labeled as 12.5%, though I don't know just how accurate that
figure was. And EstrellaRiver is certainly a warmer growing area.
One of the problems of a seminar on this subject is defining what "balance" is in Syrah. Certainly, it
implies a lower alcohol level, something well below 15%. But I've had Syrahs that were above 15% and showed
what I would call balance. Some of these winemakers have been taken to the woodshed by Parker over the quality
of their wines. It is alleged that he only appreciates Syrahs w/ power/extraction/oak/alcohol and gobs of
hedonistic fruit. But his sycophants repeatedly assure us that he also equally values wines that show
elegance/balance/finesse and restraint, and will offer up the occasional TN as evidence of such. That there
is no "Parker Palate". I remain unconvinced on that score. But it is a problem for these wines to define what
balance reeeally is. There are a lot of Syrahs out there that I like...like quite a lot...that don't fit
neatly in either camp. Like terroir or varietal character, balance is not a be-all to end-all that must be
mounted on a pedestal and worshiped from afar.
After the tasting and some comments, the floor was opened to additional questions. I asked, in my finest
pot-stirring mode, who the panelists thought were some of the poster-child winemakers who would not fit
into this Seminar. They all, wisely, quietly demurred on naming any such people. I then asked who they thought
should be here, but were not. EhrenJordan was the one they mostly agreed upon. Also mentioned were Nick&Andy
Peay and John&KimCabot. I would include, probably, EricSussman, TomDehlinger, JasonHaas, Morgan Twain-
Peterson, Tracey&Jared Brandt, and KurtBeitler.
RajParr's Anika Syrah was made sans-soufre. I asked him how come his san-soufre was so good and what did
he do differently from the "great" sans-soufre wines made by TonyCoturri (again in my finest pot-stirring
mode). Raj, not knowing me, was a bit taken aback by this question. Fortuntely, one of the panelists (who
does know me well and my pot-stirring proclivities) chimed in with "Raj takes a shower every day", to much
amusement all around.
When Bob invited me to this seminar and outlined the parameters, I was expecting the discussion to
contain a lot of Parker-bashing and discussions on point-whores. But, surprise/surprise...the elephant
sitting in the room was not mentioned once by name the entire discussion. I daresay that certain Monktown
attourneys might have found much to like in this tableau of upper-80's to low-90's point wines. But
probably not a 95+ pt wine would be found here, though. Fine with me.
That night, they repeated the tasting at the RN74 restaurant in TheCite, but w/o the Seminar and the
trouble-makers in the audience to stir things up.
Tom