Day 4
Sunday, all day at my place - relaxed format, plenty of food, simple fare - lots of warmth, plenty of shade, no rain. Yes!
Dishes served -
Turkish dips and bread
Crumbed blackfish bites and yes, I caught the fish
Side of smoked Tasmanian Salmon served with a bevy of condiments - capers, red onion, sour cream, chives, lemons etc.
Salt and pepper beer batter prawns
Chicken kebabs served with coban salad and rice
Kofta with chilli and homuss dips
Eye fillet kebabs served with a turkish bean salad
Floating Euro lemon tarts (abandoned)
Rich chocolate cake (good-on-ya Rach and friend!)
Coffee and truffles
The Wines - not exactly in order opened
Hugel Gewurztraminer Selection de Grains Nobles 1998 - in incredible shape - luscious and exotic but holding wonderful poise and still remarkably fresh, finishing dry. Didn't notice the 15% A/V.
93
Laurent-Perrier Vintage Brut 1996 - most excellent displaying a very tight personality. To me this wine has a long way to go - approachable yes, but will be better over the next several years
91
Lindemans Reserve Pinot Noir/Chardonnay/Pinot Meunier 1999 - Not Tasted - only opened for mouth rinsing purposes only
- actually previous bottles opened were pretty darn good FWII - paid a whole 8 bucks a bottle for this retail!
Seppelt Drumborg Riesling 1999 - only tried a splash of this - looked remarkably fresh with a wealth of fruit and the first vestige of bottle development - plenty of juice still in the tank NR
Grosset Polish Hill Riesling 2002 - disappeared before I got to try any - the few comments rendered were highly positive
Mount Pleasant Elizabeth Semillon 1998 - again only a passing glimpse from me with this one - displayed a deep yellow/gold colour, plenty of development on both nose and palate - sound but not particularly exciting NR
Tyrrell's Vat 1 Semillon 1995 - right back to form after the slightly dissappointing errant bottle on Friday - top flight Hunter Sem with enormous reserves - looked young and pristine to me
92
Freycinet Chardonnay 1995 - looked solid enough without creating much excitement with the small amount I tried NR
Tyrrell's Vat 47 Chardonnay 2002 - NT - GazzaB commented this looked very young - "still a pup" were his exact words I think
Leeuwin Estate Art Series Chardonnay 2001 - thanks be to GazzaB for this one - looked awfully classy to me, tightly coiled but with a wealth of nuance on both nose and palate - lovely wine with plenty of time to go. NFR but somewhere in the 92-93 range at a guess
Trimbach Cuvee Frederic Emile Riesling 1996 en magnum - finally got to open one! Pristine bright straw green, haunting minerally Alsace bouquet with bucket loads of fruit in support. Served way too cold at first (I forgot I had it in the freezer) particularly hindering the palate (a bit short and bitter). Improved dramatically in the glass as it warmed.
92
Meo-Camuzet Vosne-Romanee 1er Cru Les Chaumes 1996 - Charming, svelte, sexy Pinot probably nearing its peak drinking window. NR but low nineties wine as a guide
Michel Lafarge Volnay Clos des Chenes 1993 - another gorgeous example very much in the style of the Meo-Camuzet, but if anything, a little better. Probably worth 94 points if you want a numerical value. A Burgundy that sang from start to finish. IMHO, the best Burgundy of the day - beating the other premier and grand crus!
Vachet-Rousseau Gevrey-Chambertin Mazis-Chambertin Grand Cru 1993 - repeat performance from the night before -masculine, beefy palate, perhaps a little unready behind a quite lovely bouquet.
90
Frederic Esmonin Chambertin-Clos-des-Beze Grand Cru 1996 - another Outstanding Burg - having trouble with descriptors here and thus won't point it but in the scheme of things I'd rate it between the Chaumes and the Lafarge, somewhere around the
91-92 points mark
Marc Pavelot Savigny-Les-Beaune Les Dominode 1999 en magnum - almost fotgot about this one! Truly Outstanding for its (lesser) station in life compared to some of the supposed big "guns"above. If anything, surpassed them! Very youthful, beautifully balanced, silky, great line - absolutely loved this, particularly the class of the fruit - and its got time on its side!
92
Rockford Black Shiraz 2005 Disgorg. - thanks be to JLo for this scintallating number - amazingly pure with bucketloads of creamy blackberry fruit - will last for yonks, methinks NR
Wynns Black label Cabernet 1998 - this was opened when I was cooking the shaslicks and didn't get a looksee
Howard Park Cabernet Merlot 1995 - I know this has received some bad press over the years for a volatile acidity problem, but this bottle looked excellent to me, extremely varietal with some similarities to a modern ripe Bordeaux with a distinctive "gravelly" character.
90 points on its ear. Thanks to IanB for this one.
Penfolds Bin 80A Cabernet Shiraz1980 - cork disintegrated on opening - a bad start - but what I strained into the decanter was absolutely stunning and way over my jittery expectations. Still with plenty of life in front of it, this red showed a deep vigorous colour, superb aromatics and smooth but concentrated palate of great length with heaps of fruit to burn. Every component meshed to perfection, IMHO. One of my top wine's of the day.
94
Penfolds Bin 707 Cabernet Sauvignon 1991 - very sound if a little unexciting and did attract some strong comments from the table when revealed. I thought the oak treatment spoilt the fruit a bit. Very good verging on excellent.
High 80's from me.
Lindemans Sesquicentenary Coonawarra Cabernet Sauvignon 1990 en magnum - does contain just a litlle less than 10% Shiraz - this looked Outstanding to me, but at this stage of the evening the sheer quantity of reds was making judgement difficult. NR
Stonyridge Waiheke Island Cabernets 1994 - an eye opener for me - right in the slot. Nothing underripe here - a gloriously rich and well-honed red with everything in place. Up there with the best of them on the day.
92 Thanks again to GazzaB for this one!
Ch. Ducru-Beaucaillou (St. Julien) 1978 - probably a few too many years past its best drinking window, but still very good although drying out a tad on the palate.
86
Ch. Leoville-las-Cases (St. Julien) 1978 - just fantastic aged Bordeaux - layered, aristocratic, lots of extremely good things going on here - if anything better than the last bottle I opened and assessed carefully.
http://www.winestar.com.au/forum/viewtopic.php?t=16029&highlight= 93
Domaine de Chevalier 1978 - this was my pick of the 1978 Bordeaux flight. Just a superb wine drinking at its apoge.
94
Zentralkellerei Ezeuger-Abfullung Ediger-Osterlammchen Beerenauslese Riesling 1976 375 ml - probably got things a bit wrong with the label - a curio GazzaB picked up for a song somewhere - very deep burnished colour, nice aromatics and an incredibly lush, unctious palate - drying out a tad but I still thought it very good - about
85 points
Ch. Suduiraut (Sauternes) 1983 - quite simply, absolutely brilliant - incredibly youthful, elegant but seriously complex in nuance of bouquet and palate, about as good as it gets for an aged Sauternes without the sheer power of D'Yquem. Bordering on exceptional -
94 points
Seppelt Rutherglen Vintage Port 1972 - made from Touriga, Bastardo and Alvarelhao - in great shape -
92 points
Seppelt Rare Rutherglen Tokay DP 59 - this really rocked my boat. Having tried this on many occasions, this bottle surpassed anything I've had previously. Cam's incredibly generous contribution the night before of a half bottle of Chambers Rare Tokay blew me away - I gave it 97 points! This was as good, if not better - words cannot do either wine justice!
98 points
A huge thank you to the gang for making the day what it was -
My terrific wife and daughters (extra-special thanks to Rachel and friend who worked like trojans)
Mum and Dad
Eric Wallace
GazzaB
Tony and Deb
JLo
Lyndsay Kerr
Rob Buettner
Toi Low
Ian Beverley
Ann Morant
Paul Heimburger
Baby Chickpea
Cam
A most moving experience!